
Detached ADU
A freestanding backyard home with its own entrance, kitchen, bath, and a sliver of private outdoor space. It is the unit most San Mateo homeowners picture when they imagine a backyard cottage, and the one renters will pay the most for.
- Maximum privacy for tenants or family
- Top of the local rent range
- Reads as a true second dwelling at resale
- Higher cost; consumes backyard footprint
Attached ADU
A unit that extends your existing home or finishes attached space — sharing a wall, roof line, and often the nearest utility runs. It keeps your backyard open and trims both cost and timeline.
- Lower up-front cost
- Preserves usable yard
- Faster to build
- Shares a wall; slightly less privacy and rent
Side by Side
| Factor | Detached | Attached |
|---|---|---|
| Up-front cost | Higher — new foundation, roof, and separate utilities | Lower — shares a wall, roof line, and sometimes a utility run |
| Privacy | Best — a standalone home with its own yard access | Good, but tenants and family share a wall with the main house |
| Rental appeal | Strongest — commands the top of the San Mateo rent range | Solid, especially for a studio or one-bedroom near transit |
| Yard impact | Occupies backyard footprint; needs 4 ft side/rear setback | Preserves open yard by extending the existing structure |
| Timeline | 6 – 9 months ground-up | 4 – 7 months depending on tie-ins |
| Resale value | Highest lift — reads as a second dwelling on the parcel | Meaningful lift, framed as added square footage plus a unit |
Which Wins on a Typical San Mateo Lot?
For a standard 5,000–7,000 sq ft San Mateo lot — think Shoreview, North Central, or the flats of San Mateo Park — a detached unit usually fits comfortably within the four-foot setbacks while leaving a functional yard, and it earns the strongest rent and resale. If you are chasing long-term income, that is the play.
An attached ADU makes more sense when the backyard is small or heavily used, when you want to move in a family member quickly and cheaply, or when an existing attached garage or lower level is begging to be finished. You trade a little privacy and top-end rent for a lower bill and a shorter build.
There is also a third path many owners miss: pairing a 500 sq ft junior ADU inside the home with a detached unit in the yard, which state law allows on many single-family parcels. We map out every option your specific lot supports during the free feasibility visit.